I recently beat this game, and I enjoyed it immensely. I was a bit surprised about the reviewer's distaste for the turntables; I guess a little puzzle challenge didn't bother me.

As for appropriateness, it is my opinion that it is not substantially darker than other entries in the Zelda series. All magic, etc. is fairy tale in character. If this was re-reviewed under our current review standards, it would rate much higher. It is not without problems, but I did not find them to be substantial worries in my opinion.

IBJamon